Every industry has a piece of jargon that deserves a comeback. In direct mail marketing, it was “champion/challenger,” a simple, disciplined way of testing new ideas against your best-performing one. It's time trade shows borrowed it.
The Original Idea
The champion/challenger model comes out of direct mail and response-based marketing, where testing different offers against each other with variations of the strategy has been standard practice since the 1960s. The logic is straightforward: whatever piece is currently driving the best return, the “champion,” stays in the lead position. Every new idea, the “challenger,” gets tested against it under the same conditions. If the challenger wins, it becomes the new champion. If it doesn't, the champion stays put, and you go build another challenger.
The approach ensures constant improvement and evolution while not sacrificing high performers. In some cases a champion approach may last for years. The important key is that learning never ceases and when a shift in the market does occur or new advancements enter, a team using this approach will catch it early. What made it powerful wasn't the testing mechanic itself; it was the mindset behind it. Nothing was sacred. No piece, no matter how well it performed, was exempt from being challenged.
Why This Matters Beyond Direct Mail
Direct mail has largely been replaced by digital channels, and with it, a lot of organizations quietly let the champion/challenger discipline fade away too. That's a mistake, because the philosophy was never really about postage and reply cards or even the “mail” channel in general. It was about refusing to let past success become the reason you stop improving.
That applies just as directly to trade shows. Best practices in the B2B Trade Show and Exposition industry exist for good reason: they're often the accumulated wisdom of what has worked, tested informally over years by people who know the business. But best practices have a shadow side. Followed too rigidly, for too long, they stop being “the smart way to do things” and start being “the way we've always done things.” Those are not the same, and the difference is where stagnation lives. And stagnation is death for your event or business.
There has never been a single trade show, not the biggest, not the fastest-growing, not the most profitable, that held onto that title by standing still. Every show that has stayed on top for more than a single moment in time got there through a continuous, sometimes uncomfortable cycle of questioning its own playbook.
What Champion/Challenger Looks Like at a Trade Show
You don't need a testing platform or a statistics degree to run this. You need a habit and a bit of structure.
Start by identifying your champions: the practices currently in place because they work. Registration flow, floor layout logic, sponsorship packages, the format of your opening keynote, how you onboard first-time exhibitors. These aren't up for debate because they're broken; they're up for debate because everything eventually can be improved, and complacency is the actual risk. Challenging the most successful things you do is what drives innovation. Challenging things that aren’t working just fixes a problem that needed to be addressed anyway.
Build success-driven challengers. This works best as a group exercise rather than something left to one person's imagination. Get people from different parts of the organization (sales, operations, marketing, even exhibitors themselves) into a room and ask one question repeatedly: is there a way this could be better, either for the show or for the customer? Not “is this good enough”; that invites a shrug. “Could this be better” invites an idea. For this exercise, kick the mentality of, “don’t fix what isn’t broken” out to the curb. Fix your stagnation mindset and move forward.
Not every challenger needs to launch immediately, and most won't beat the champion on the first try. That's fine. The value isn't in overhauling everything at once; it's in building a bank of vetted ideas you can pull from when the moment is right: a new hall, a new year, a competitor move, a shift in exhibitor expectations. When that moment comes, you're not starting from a blank page. You already have challengers warmed up and ready to go.
Make It a Habit, Not a Project
The organizations that do this well don't treat it as an occasional innovation offsite. They build the question into the culture: before every show, during show hours, after every show, after every major initiative, someone asks what the challenger version would have looked like. Over time, that question becomes reflexive rather than special.
This is also a retention tool, even though it doesn't look like one at first glance. Exhibitors and sponsors renew with shows that feel like they're getting better, not just repeating themselves. A champion/challenger mentality signals, to your team and your customers, that you're paying attention, that you're not coasting on last year's success.
Stagnation rarely announces itself. It shows up quietly, as a schedule that hasn't changed in three years, a floor plan nobody has questioned since the venue was booked, a sponsorship tier structure that made sense in a different market. Champion/challenger is the antidote, not because it guarantees every new idea is a winner, but because it guarantees the old ideas never stop being tested.
Your champion best practice at some time earned its spot. Make sure it has to keep earning it.
Write A Comment